So I have an idea...
I read the one red paperclip page today. I'd heard about it shortly after it started... I don't remember exactly when. It's irrelevant. I didn't really follow the story until I heard recently that he'd met his goal - he got his house. Well done.
But reading his posts, I think he's missed the point of bartering a bit. He's all about the Funtential. Don't get me wrong, that's a great thing. But I think it misses a more fundamental point to the trades. The real point is that both parties benefit. I'm sure he's aware that this is happening, but focusing on the funtential diverts from the true purpose, which is to trade. Sure, trading is the point of bartering - that's a tautology. What I'm getting at is more nuanced than that, and it relies on the definition of a fair trade. For me, a fair trade means one where both parties give up something of slightly less value to them for something of slightly more value to them. The key to a fair trade is that the differences in the two values for both people is perceived to be roughly equal. That way, both parties benefit.
The last part is the key. Funtential is just an alternate way to try and quantify and compare what is being traded (money being the current favorite). Absolutely a wonderful idea - and worthy of much further investigation. But for me, the key is simply that both parties benefit. This is what I'd like to focus on and see if we can't explore.
Consider...
All in all, I'm pretty comfortable with my life right now. I've got a nice apartment in a good neighborhood, in a wonderful country. I've got a good job. I've got a car, paid for. I have no debts... just rent, and a credit card bill I pay off every month. I've saved up enough cash for a rainy day fund, and I'm well on my way to having a good nest egg. I have enough cash for occasional trips abroad, and I've recently hooked up with a wonderful friend. Life's just pretty darn good.
So much so that I feel I really should be sharing some of this good fortune.
I've been helping my family here and there, but really, what's next? Money only goes so far, and to be honest, I'm not so flush I can afford to keep dropping the same amount of cash on an ever expanding circle of family and friends.
So... what to do?
Plenty of charities exist that will gladly take the cash and redistribute it, but there's always concerns - which is the best? Which has the least overhead? How much of my donation actually goes to where I want it to go - the people in need? How can I be sure the people in the system won't just take the cash and run? Charities often become large corperations and we all know how popular those are these days. It's hard to have a lot of trust and faith in a large company. In charity, smaller, local organizations are better.
Last year, I donated to the Penny-Arcade Child's Play charity... but that was down in Seattle. Not bad, just outside my local area. I'm a big fan of the "Think Globally, Act Locally" philosophy. Too bad the guys over at PA don't have anything up here in the Great White North yet, eh?
So it occured to me... why not combine all this?
Why not start a red-paperclip/Child's Play donation fund?
The system I've come up with is:
- I start with an item I have and don't want - for example, a solid, but used, computer desk, or the entertainment stand collecting dust in the closet.
- I offer the item for trade on Craig's List (or possibly the red-paperclip page - or maybe get one thing going on each?)
- The rules of the trade:
- I'll accept something of roughly the same value as what I'm trading
- the recipient has to throw in a "sweetener" for the deal, in the form of a new, in box & shrink wrap:
- video game
- game system
- game system peripheral
Bargin-bin games are ok, as long as they're new. Like the Playstation2 Greatest Hits series, Xbox Platinum series, etc. New because I understand charities prefer toys and such to be in that condition when they're redistributing them. I'll look into it - maybe we can do some donations with like new?
Anyway, at the end, I donate everything to the Vancouver Children's Hospital.
Though come to think of it, I may want to try and set up something like what PA has with Child's Play - when you donate you buy from Amazon.com and it ships directly to the hospital. A more direct connection which bolsters belief that the item you've donated gets where it needs to be. I've got a friend at the VCH, so I'll see what's involved.
Look for another post soon, hopefully with a couple links - one to Craig's List and one to Amazon.ca. ;)
Peace Out.
-Greg




